ULTA vs CASY — Key Metrics

Metric ULTA (ULTA BEAUTY INC) CASY (CASEYS GENERAL STORES INC)
Price648.51698.67
Market Cap27.73 Billion25.82 Billion
P/E (TTM)23.5633.46
P/B (Quarterly)8.7356.622
P/S (TTM)2.141.38
Net Profit Margin (TTM)9.34.1
Gross Margin (TTM)39.323.8
ROE (TTM)45.419.7
Revenue Growth YoY (TTM)n/an/a

Upfront Investment - S&P 500 Stock Comparison & AI Analysis

AI-powered analysis and comparison tools for S&P 500 stocks, helping investors make data-driven decisions with delayed market data and portfolio modeling.

ULTA BEAUTY INC
vs
 
CASEYS GENERAL STORES INC
 
ULTA BEAUTY INC
vs
 
CASEYS GENERAL STORES INC
Performance Comparison
AI Model Recommendation
ULTA · ULTA BEAUTY INC

Underperform

-48
UnderperformOutperform
CASY · CASEYS GENERAL STORES INC

Greatly Underperform

-90
UnderperformOutperform
Recommendation Summary

Stock ULTA is projected to underperform the market, stock CASY is projected to greatly underperform the market. Upfront Recommendation: ULTA.

Financial Metrics
Prices delayed ~15 min
ULTA Metrics CASY
$648.51 Price $698.67
— Market Capitalization —
23.56 Price to Earnings Ratio 33.46
2.14 Price to Sales 1.38
24.12 Price to FCF Ratio 38.14
5.44 Price to Gross Profit 5.81
9.04 Price to Current Assets 18.59

ULTA vs CASY at a glance

Ulta Beauty INC (ULTA) and Caseys General Stores INC (CASY) are both Specialty Retail companies in the Consumer Cyclical sector. They are similar in size: $27.7 billion and $25.8 billion in market value.

On trailing-twelve-month figures, ULTA trades at 23.6 times trailing earnings and CASY at 33.5; net profit margins are 9.3% and 4.1%.

The Upfront Investment model currently rates ULTA Underperform and CASY Greatly Underperform as of November 18, 2026. The rating ranks the model's medium-term return forecast against the other stocks it scores; it is a statistical forecast, not investment advice.